Why do Muslims need reservation?




because they are Muslims
8% (77 votes)
because they are backward
68% (668 votes)
to appease them
19% (188 votes)
no opinion
5% (44 votes)
Total votes: 977

Comments

for reservation

in India Muslims are too poor in all angles every state should give reservation

I am against reservation. I

I am against reservation. I am also a musim... but i am standing on my legs with the grace of Allah and hard work. Reservation will makes people more lazy and nothing more. Work hard on muslims to expalin them the importance of education and what kind of education and skills are must be gained to be a winner. Simply graduating from a third class colleges by third class marks with poor english skills will be of no use.

Fine..one is out of competition in our 10%..Cheers up All bro's

Hai Ahamed ..

Salam/.

Fine to hear u are no need of reservation..

good..

Here in the competition within 10% of Reservation what we are gonna get in Central Reservation ,one gone away..thats u.

we are so happy to hear, u are going away of 10%..

u can fight in reaming % of OC's..

Have a happy day dear..

The reason why Muslims are

The reason why Muslims are backward is that we don't follow family planning because of which we tend to become financially unsound. It is high time
that every faithful muslim starts following to have a prosperous family.

reservation for muslims

Assalamualaykum,

Dear muslim brothers,

The reservation in any form is a menace. What has happened to SC/ST and other reservation? The beneficiaries have made it their right in the name of constitution. We all see in our daily lives the situation in all government and semi government services. The deserved ones are rolling down the earth.

We demand reservation because the muslims are suppressed and humiliated by the higher caste Hindus in a similar way the SCs & STs are subjected to yet the minds of muslims who understand Tawheed and other communities fall apart as an earth from sky. The mental position of muslims can not be compared to that of others. We need reservation. And rightly we need to show the world that the problems in the world can be solved through muslims only.

If we do on our own, we are doing double

Dear Muslim Indians,

If we follow the way of Allah, we are sure to succeed in this world and the Aakhirat. Lets pool our Zakaat and khairaat instead of directly spending them on the poor. A part of the same could be used to uplift the people at large. We are responsible to our non-Muslim brethren as well because we cannot be a Muslim if our neighbour (practising any religion) is in need of anything. If we are able to part some part of our wealth instead of leaving it for our offspring, they would be the last to remember you. While they are not be brought on road, we'd do better to give part of our wealth for the needy. Surely, Allah's help would follow you. Many times I experienced this and has firmly decided to do the same. Even if I am not able to carry that out and die, I am hopeful that Allah would reward me just for the 'niyyat' I have. May Allah allow me to carry out my thoughts. It is upto him. Please remember me in your dua specially for this purpose. May Allah reward success so that any poor, Muslim or otherwise is not dependent of people who are responsible for their plight. Ameen!!

Very good thoughts,

Very good thoughts, reservation is not the solution for any problem, neither i think Muslims are backwards, they are very much modern in their thoughts, in their actions and in their minds. if it was so, then i guess we need to question the credibility of Muslims on higher ranks world wide.

However, i do believe their is some sort discrimination, which is almost in every non-Islamic country. even in US (although its president himself is a Muslim) there is some discrimination in the system.

This reservation is not going to help, but instead, it will increase the panic line. Reservation is required for a challenged community, i don't feel Muslims are challenged from any where, they are very much capable from all aspects, However, there should be region based reservations instead of caste or religion based.

if wakf properties are

if wakf properties are mainted properly and take current rates(rents) we can do on our own?
congress being in power can not pass a law which give power to wakf to vacate illegal occupation

if wakf properties are...

If WAQF properties throughout India are used properly, revenues generated from that will solve most Muslim's problems.

But GOI controls activities of WAQF boards and properties, and abuses board member's authorities for benefit of other community.

Just a cursory ANALYSIS of WAQF properties throughout India, and it's benefits - if used properly for benefit of those, whom it is designated (i.e. Muslims) will give readers a SHOCK.

Local land-grabbers, SS / RSS goons, and most politicians know about WAQF properties potential - but their "hands are tied".

An Indian

muslim reservations

we want muslim reservations

Reservation

Reservation is not discrimination, we the muslims wants reservation, with reservation it does not meant that we are grabing the chance one meritorious general, reservation is for bringing the backward muslims to forefront, and to make par with others who are enjoying the benefits of development...

Muslim reservation

Muslim reservation is the need of the time. I know we are not backward to claim for reservation but if government will have a second eye then any forward community will become backward within not less than 40-50 years. Thats what happened with Muslims in India. No country can be developed until all society will be in respectable position, all will have equal right for education and equal opportunity in jobs. If government consider that we are one important part of the vehicle then the part has to be repaired to reach the destination called "developed country".

Islamic Banking

Why are we making loud noises on adopting Islamic Banking? The point of basic survival of banking is savings. Right? Where is the concept of savings in Islam? Is there any?

interest free loan

i want to know about interest free loan

muslims need reservation

muslims community is a backward community in India. There share in civil services is less than 5 percent. Government should ensure that only economically backward section of the get community gets reservation.. The Muslim community has over the last 60 years remained marginalised in all walks of life. They have been victims of both direct and indirect discrimination. They have been victims of both direct and indirect discrimination. A special effort has been done to bring them to the mainstream.The condition of Muslims in India is no better than that of SC/STs. Muslims were not seeking reservations as a favour from the GOVERNMENT, but as a RIGHT.

Economically, politically and socially, Muslims are backward

Economically, politically and socially, Muslims are backward. Indian constitution guarantees the equal right for everyone, so we are not begging; we are demanding your right.

Ahmed bhai, Well said… what about the people how are stricken with poverty?? Let them die because they born in poor family rite??

Take an Exmaple: As of now also we have many talented muslims in india, and they are doing exceptionally well outside india, Then why we don’t have muslims in govt office Like RBI, Army, PSU Banks, and many other PSU company….

It’s because, The hindutva brigade systematically, denying our rights.

The only solution is bringing the weak people of the society to main stream, by give reservation in all sectors, not only in Education, economically and politically as well.

Muslims are backward BUT NOT educationally or by talents

I agree with Syed Abidali's comments @ Feb. 17, 2010 : 9:31 pm

I have a Brahmin Classmate, and we always did combined-studies. I know his standard and caliber, as I was always first in class, and he was way down. We both appeared for "Class-IV" service commission exam. I failed, and he passed, got job, and now, he is Asst. Commissioner Rank.

Readers should know about "white thread" magic - which is BLESSED to Brahmin Males at birth. They just show the "white thread", and that magic works WONDERS - in school / college admissions, service-commission exams, jobs, wherever SPECIAL FAVOURS, are needed.

I am just trying to convey, how favouritism of "white thread" works wonders, and side-lines other TALENTED Indians, including Muslims.

I could not but emphasize, that RESERVATION is necessary for uplifting community, and to dilute favouritism.

An Indian

Your thinking is backward

Muslims are educationally, economically backward because just like your thinking they are backward in they they think. Wow what an example to show how "intelligent" person like you can lose to a "un-intelligent" brahmin. Poor thing, your white thread friend is not here, or else we would have really known how "stupid" you are.

Mugging up needs no brains

Mugging up needs no brains and will get anyone good marks in class 12 Exams. But application of that knowledge in a competitive exam needs intelligence because questions for competitive Exams are not directly asked from test books.

I know of a twins who studied in the same school and class from class 1-12 and the GIRL always scored 8-10% more than the BOY in every exam including class 12. But for the entrance test for BTech, the boy was about 4000 ranks ahead of the GIRL and got selected to better collage. Such things do happen and attributing it as discrimination is totally incorrect. Muslims are trying to find fault with everything Indian.

Mugging and white thread magic.....

Thank you Mr. Giri and AK Singh for your comments.

I FORGOT to WRITE about my earlier SUCCESS in "Armed Forces" non-commissioned officers exam, and my friends' FAILURE. I could not join armed forces, as I was below 18-years, and parental consent was necessary - and my friend could not join, for FAILING written exam.

I was NOT trying to convey my failure in Group-IV exam, but the message was to emphasize "white-thread" magic, and caste-discrimination, prevalent to-date in India.

Thank you both for your valuable comments. I got the message viewing the latest movie "Three Idiots", and I don't need "FREE advice".

An Indian

P.S.: On Nov. 1st 1984, I was the first one to call my best friend, a SARDAR to rush-home and take cover, to protect himself and his family from Anti-Sikh Riots. To-date, he still remembers that call, and thanks me. But I always tell him, that I did my duty as a BEST-FRIEND.

Skull cap hatred towards white thread

..is all well known. It is a losers mentality. Muslims are backward because of their thinking like yours. It is a veiled attack on anything that is hindus.

---
I had to reformat because my previous comment was not published..

govt is failed to provide equal opportunity

Giri, you mean to say Dr B R Ambedkar is looser… who advocated the reservation policy for backward class??

Reservation is necessary because, govt is failed to provide equal opportunity to all community,

Those who are in power, they are systematically, denying our right…

Now you will argue on saying “We are not competitive“. This is not the truth.

govt is failed to provide equal opportunity to all community

Giri, you mean to say Dr B R Ambedkar is looser… who advocated the reservation policy for backward class??

Reservation is necessary because, govt is failed to provide equal opportunity to all community,

Those who are in power, they are systematically, denying our right…

Now you will argue on saying “We are not competitive“. This is not the truth.

Muslim Reservations

Abidali, No Ambedkar was not loser. He advocated reservations at that time which was correct and he himself wanted to put a limit on reservations after few decades. But our greedy politicians kept continuing to play their vote bank politics.
What has reservations achieved till now and if the really deserving ones able to get it? No. It is only low caste powerful leaders who enjoy the lifetime benefits. Now it has become holy cow and no body can touch it, lest there will be immolations, bandhs and political seats at stake.

Reservation is temporary need... which must be addressed

Giri, I sympathize with your view, but experience has shown that individuals, especially those at the bottom of the ladder have no power to get redress from systematic discrimination. The only way though imperfect is to implement the temporary reservation policy for the discriminated groups based on religion.

We are not asking more then what we deserve (give us at least 10% of share for Muslims, which is guaranteed by Indian constitution). As of now statistic shows that only 1-2% Representation of Muslims in the Administration of Indian Government.

Coming back to your argument "If you look at the historical statistic about SC/ST...They are benefited lot because of reservation policy".

Reservation is temporary need... which must be addressed.

15% reservation is the need

Dear Brothers,
Salam Masnoon,
The rangnath misra report has been out it recommends 15% Reservation for Muslims in Education & employment.
Also Recommends Inclusion of Muslim & Christian Dalits in SC List.
They are saying that muslims are eligible for reservation, now it is our right to snatch that, I am wondered seeing that someone is not willing for reservation .
The second thing which is recommended that to include muslim dalits in SC list is very important.

Reply to muslims who dont want reservation

Salam/.
Some muslims says that they do not want reservation, brother think about other backward regions, if u are staying in a good city with good education and earning so its fine that if u dont get reservation, but think about muslims who are in tribal belt of india and they are earning less than 30RS a day, so do they not deserve reservation to come up in Education, government jobs, medical assistance, etc.
So please if you are giving opinion then for whole community then think befor you say anything.

Muslim Reservation

Reservation is very important for the muslim community in India. India can never become a super power without improving muslims' condition since muslims are also a part of india. I have best friends from all communities and I am not having any hatred against any human being, but it is true that generally it is very difficult to find good employment in India if you are a muslim(if you do not have any influence). Let me tell you one incident. In 1982 BHEL factory started in Ranipet (Tamil Nadu). Myself and my best friend(Brahmin), both Physics graduates applied there for employment and we both got interviews.Only my friend(Brahmin) was selected and went for medical fitness test.But he failed in medical and again approached the manager(also a Brahmin). The Manager got angry with him for not wearing white thread during medical test. My friend again went for medical fitness test with white thread and got selected.After trying so many years to find good employment, my poverty forced me to start a footpath shop to sell used garments and plastic items in the bazzar. Very tough life. After long struggle, I was able to move legally to a western country and now I am very successful educator and businessman. It is my sincere opinion that currently muslims' condition/status is very pathetic in India.

hatred towards white threads

You have a jaundiced persona that you reflect through your venomous comments against so called white threads. So, your point is basically what all brahmins achieved is not through their intelligence or hard work but through recommendation and cheating. If this is pretty much the thinking of your entire Ummah, then no wonder yours is a big pathetic loser community. What have your islamic brothers from your other countries achieved? What is their contribution to the science and society. Do you say you invented how to strap and reduce population? Do you think all the Indian Nobel Laurettes CV Raman, SB Chadrasekhar, Ramakrishnan, and mathematician Ramanujam to name a few, have shown their white threads to get the recognition that they achieved. OR may be you don't care the Kafir recognition which is against islamic shariah in which case you should;t even be whining to start with.

----
why has this not published?

Hatred is not to white thread

Hatred is not to white thread but is towards intelligent brilliance. Indian Muslims are "intelligently challenged" as they have mix-bread with Afghans/ Arabs who are plain stupid. They can NOT compete on equal terms with the General category HINDUS and are demanding reservation hoping that MUSLIMS may out perform the SC/ST which is a UTOPIAN dream as the SC/ST are also equally intelligent and have been given reservation due to social discrimination they faced for centuries. Muslims who ruled India for Centuries will never be granted reservation.

Another comment about "White Thread" Magic

AK Singh and Mr. Giri need to read latest comment from: "Purely Indian", dated 20 February 2010 - 11:32pm. And his experience of Ranipet, Tamilnadu dates back to 1982.

I believe, "white thread" magic is practiced in India, for centuries - but was more hidden. And, in my opinion that's one MAJOR REASON, there is no "unemployment" for Brahmins and other high-castes. And that's also the main reason for backward conditions of minorities, in India.

Shame on you AK Singh and Mr. Giri - for defending "white thread" practice (discrimination), and for NOT accepting facts !!!

An Indian

Skull caps shouldn't throw venom against 'white thread'

You have a jaundiced persona that you reflect through your venomous comments against so called white threads. So, your point is basically what all brahmins achieved is not through their intelligence or hard work but through recommendation and cheating. If this is pretty much the thinking of your entire Ummah, then no wonder yours is a big pathetic loser community. What have your islamic brothers from your other countries achieved? What is their contribution to the science and society. Do you say you invented how to strap and reduce population? Do you think all the Indian Nobel Laurettes CV Raman, SB Chadrasekhar, Ramakrishnan, and mathematician Ramanujam to name a few, have shown their white threads to get the recognition that they achieved. OR may be you don't care the Kafir recognition which is against islamic shariah in which case you should;t even be whining to start with.

Giri my point is..... read this.....

Mr. Giri, my point is DISCRIMINATION / BIAS / INJUSTICE / SUPPRESSION / ABUSE of minorities. Read this article:

http://twocircles.net/2010feb22/terror_acquittal_five_years_lost_prove_h...

I can give you scores of such instances, where innocents have been wrongly arrested, held and are made to suffer for the rest of their lives; just because of EXCESSES committed by OR at instigation of High-Castes; which are being done on this land for centuries, and are done to-date. Thank you.

An Indian

An Indian is digressing

You are digressing from the subject. Your original subject was how Brahmins are shown favour in jobs while musims are discriminated. If that is so, you wont have Azeem Premji, a muslim, to have become the richest Indian in a land of 800M hindus. You cannot equate a few incidents of locking up of youth to complete discrimination of 200M muslims in education.

CASTE-war is in India for centuries - thread is misplaced

If "Skull caps" can handle "four wives", it's easy to manage four commentators at a time.

Mr. Giri - I responded to your statement on Feb. 18th 2010 and the "thread" is misplaced - but it under same article. I believe you ignored to read my earlier posting.

My latest posting of even date, is of-course DIVERTING from subject, as you failed OR ignored to respond to my previous statement of Feb. 18th 2010.

The CASTE-war is on in India, from centuries. So there is no question of surrender - Mr. Giri. Accept facts as they are. You know very well - and everyone realized it's practice; but lately !!!

As the saying is true: It's better LATE, than NEVER.

An Indian

Read Indian History from 1720 to 1840 to better understand

Read Indian History from 1720 to 1840 to better understand Indian History. 120 years is long period which is not discussed by any one. Also find out HOW and WHEN did SIS GANJ GURUDWARA come up on Chandini Chowk, 800 meters form the LAORE GARE of RED FORT the capital of AURANGI who ordered the beheading of SIKH GURU- Teg Bahadur at the location were SIS GUNJ GURUDWARA atands today. OR visit the museum in GOLDEN TEMPLE in Amristar. IT WILL BE EVIDENT "who were FIGHTING whom" in India and if you read on upto Indian History till 1862, it will be evident as to how NORTH India has HINDU majority even after centuries of ISLAMIC rule.

Are you aware that the SIKHS stormed Sirhind in 1710, where the two children of Guru Gobind Singh were murdered, and killed every muslim.

Are you aware that JATS captured FATEHPUR SIKRI, took out the bones of AKBAR and burned it.

You cannot undo PAST. But you can spoil PRESENT by....

I read your comment LGBT "Anonymous". I have one thing to say, and that is a saying:

YOU cannot UNDO the PAST, but

YOU can "spoil" the PRESENT, by

WORRYING about FUTURE.

An Indian

P.S.:
------
Indian Politicians (under cover of Religion), and their BLIND SUPPORTERS, are HELL BENT on SPOILING the PRESENT - affecting NOT ONLY minorities, but all INDIANS.

azim premji - one muslim

azim premji - one
muslim youth locked up - in thousands

you wont have Azeem Premji, a muslim, to have become the richest Indian in a land of 800M hindus. You cannot equate a few incidents of locking up of youth to complete discrimination of 200M muslims in education.

your above statement itself shows the kind of discrimination muslims faces in their own land.

and by the way azim premji is bhora a subsect of ismailism [ i would prefer not to call them ismaili muslim], does anybody knows what they do at their so called sacred place jamat khana .... so called cultural programmes such as dandiya and other form of dance which in particularly performed by ladies and spectator which inclued both men and women.

does islam allows a man to see and enjoy women dancing.

question oneself ?

Reservation means condemning to a socially unenviable status!

The British Raj ,soon after India's first war of independence (1857) decided to discriminate the Muslims and woo the Hindus! The Muslim mullahs also contributed much for the isolation of Muslims because of their poor knowledge about sciences.(They did not know that the Golden Era of Islamic Sciences oonly led the West to make further strides!)So in a gap of nearly 30 years the Hindus acquired western education and got good positions. Muslim intellectuals like Sir Syed Amed Khan & others tried to open new schools and colleges for Muslims in 1927!When Indian National Congress predominately a Hindu political outfir started the freedom movement, The Raj provided reservation for Muslims to spite the others.Between 1927 and 1947 the few educated Muslims clamoured for a separate land- Pakistan!So the cleavage became all the more.Finally India was divided and Pakistan created.Thanks to their lack of diplomacy, the Pakistanis lost the eastern province and a new nation emerged as Bangladesh!Moreover during their 63 years of existence, they were under military dictators rather than under a democratic setup!Some political parties patronaged
fundamntalist groups. Now that Frankenstein is making life miserable for them.
The growth of a community should not be at the expence of the Sae but its own.The leaders of the community must try to let the Muslims come out successful in every field of humnan endeavour.Hence, their cry for reservation will condemn the Muslims as Dalits have been done.

WE PROUD ON OUR RELIGION

We get reservation because we hate non muslim activities. Non muslim came in this world without any aim of life, like animal they sex, child birth, earn money, eat enjoy and die. This is summerise of non-muslim life, But we muslim know the aim of our coming to this world, We have to be in front of Allah one day after death where we have to explain, how did we pass our examination hall life (World life) we have not come in this world by our aim, effort. Some powerful entity has sent us to prepare and again return to Allah. If we get succeed we may be allowed to enter again in Heaven otherwise hell is for permanent living place of failed candidates.

Muhammad Jamil

I Protest Mr Muhammad Jamil

Dear Mr Muhammad Jamil,

I strongly oppose your senseless observation that “Non muslim came in this world without any aim of life, like animal they sex, child birth, earn money, eat enjoy and die. This is summerise of non-muslim life, But we muslim know the aim of our coming to this world”. Every religion on earth has preached both duties and goals to its followers. The very reason of following a religion is to fulfill those duties and to reach the goal. Even if one is an atheist he too is strictly following all social norms and fulfilling his duties and obligations towards his family as well as his country. If you feel that being a Muslim you are alone given an aim and all are wandering like animal you urgently need to take an appointment of a psychologist at the earliest possible. All the best sir get well soon.

How can one gain "Moksha" ???

Mr. Ram Krishna Paswan - I accept your protest in earnest and whole-heartedly.

But how can a person gain "Moksha", if a person SEES, SUPPORTS, or REMAINS SILENT at those who are resorting to violence, killing innocents, protecting criminals, wrongly-accusing innocents, supports abuses by ELECTED REPRESENTATIVES.

What's this, if not ARROGANCE / IGNORANCE / BIAS / INJUJSTICE ???

I am amazed, reading your concluding sentences. You show the same STUPIDITY as Muhammad Jamil's comments.

Amamazed

Who told U that we are Silent !

Dear Ammazed I am amazed at your utter ignorance of the happenings around. You seem to believe that only Muslims are fighting the injustice that is being done in society (may be against their community at least) almost single handedly, and all other religious people have become mute spectators to this bloody drama. Don’t you care to think a while before coming to such cheap conclusions? I can only pity you if you have not identified any Non-Muslims in forefront in movements meant for demanding justice to the oppressed Muslims. Just take your time train your mind to be unbiased and to observe the people who are highlighting the oppression (against Muslims alone) if you still do not find persons from other religions you too can talk like Mr Jamil. My concluding sentences are to be seen in reference with Mr Jamil’s comments only as I was answering to his stupid comments which sounds as if Muslims are the only people who were send with an aim and all others are leading an aimless animal type of life. Thanks for writing me back.

Communal Violence Bill Protest weblink

Thank you Mr. Rama Krishna Paswan @ 24 February 2010 - 2:08 pm - for your response, confirming others in India are "not mute spectators" to the bloody drama. If what you write IS CORRECT, let's then PROTEST the "Communal Violence" Bill, which is placed in parliament, and for which politicians are deciding Indian Citizens fate.

Once the CV (Communal Violence) Bill is passed "in present form" it ONLY "benefits / protects" Politicians, Police, and Government Administration. Common INDIANS will be LOSERS, whether minorities, Muslims, Christians, or majority community. If YOU ARE WISE, you will realize it negatively affects "every common Indian".

I want readers to click on following, and lodge their protest to change the CV bill - so Government at SANSAD revises the BILL to suit Indian citizen's rights - not just protecting POLICE / POLITICIANS / GOI or State Governments. Here is the web-link for your action - folks / readers

http://www.anhadin.net/article101.html

Please take a few minutes and do your part, or choose/elect to remain affected for the rest of your life (lives), and for generations to suffer from ATROCITIES at HANDS of OUR POLICE, POLITICIANS, ADMINISTRATORS, JUDICIARY.

Also please take time to pass the web-link to your friends, contacts, and relatives - to do their part.

Thank you

Amamazed

P.S.:
------
Just casting our votes and sitting calm is INCORRECT. We have to question, demand, and ask: what our elected politicians are doing in SANSAD i.e. are they helping us OR are they stabbing on our backs, abusing our vote / support?

Re: Communal Violence Bill Protest weblink

I am trying to understand the content of this proposed bill, I have meanwhile passed the link http://www.anhadin.net/article101.html to all my contacts with request to understand it and act accordginly.

Thanks for the information.

Ram Krishna Paswan

Lets ensure CV bill is not passed in SANSAD in current form

Thank you Mr. Ram Krishna Paswan for passing the web-link to your contacts. Let's ensure the CV (Communal Violence) Bill does not pass in SANSAD in it's present form, without including People's Demands.

If it does pass in it's present form, it would amount to:

CUTTING OUR HANDS and GIFTING TO POLITICIANS in a PLATE.

Thank you

An Indian

Educated Kerala Muslims are not backward.

MUSLIMS haven't slipped due to discrimination but because they waste time by-hearting QUR'AN while they should be studying. During vacations when other children prepare for the studies ahead, Muslim Children attend QUR'AN classes wearing skull cap. So they are left behind in competitive exams are seeking easy way out by demanding reservation. Educated Kerala Muslims are not backward.

When one minority group-MUSLIMS alone feel that they have "GROWN BACKWARD" while all other minorities in India- SIKHS, JAINS, BUDDHIST, JEWS, PARSEE etc do not feel so, it obvious that the IDEOLOGY OF ISLAM has failed the Muslims resulting in their backwardness. Indian Muslims must convert to another religion to improve their living standard and could convert to SIKHISM as ISLAM and SIKHISM have many commonalities. More importantly SIKHS are a smaller minority than MUSLIMS but a more prosperous one.

Watch "MY NAME IS KHAN" it gives morals for all

Thank you for your comment LGBT "Anonymous" for your suggestion. Please watch bollywood movie MY NAME IS KHAN.

The title of the movie is somewhat mis-leading, but the movie message is not. I am not a fan of either Shahrukh Khan or Karan Johar (Producer), but the movie is kind of different from the title.

Clear your eye-lenses, if you are wearing. Or better still, clear your brain and thinking towards others !!!

An Indian

Have Watched MNIK- what is so special

Watched MNIK- it shows that
1. A Muslim man marries a HINDU Single mother, converts her to Islam and even the HINDU CHILD of her is not spared. Even though the HINDU CHILD has not attained "legal age to give consent" for conversion being a minor, the child is converted and named KHAN.
2. The child gets killed in the school because of his conversion to ISLAM and name- KHAN.
3. The distort HINDU women accuses the MUSLIM MAN for the death of her son - because of conversion to ISLAM and leaves the MUSLIM MAN to re-start life as a Hindu. Then melodrama starts- hurricane, heroism etc etc.

4. The tragedy would NOT have occurred if the MUSLIM MAN had 1-- converted to HINDUISM as the women and her child, TWO out of THREE were Hindus OR 2-- not forced the HINDU WOMEN and CHILD to convert to ISLAM OR 3-- at least NOT converted the HINDU CHILD allowing him to grow up as a good human being and left the option of conversion to ISLAM after he becomes 21 years of age.

CONVERSION to ISLAM was the cause of tragedy. So Indian Muslims can opt to convert to Indian religions to "escape the tragedy they face".

The message of My Name Is Khan...... is not your delusion.....

The message / moral of the movie IS NOT, as you delusionise. TRUE message, as I learned is:

a) Hindus (Gujarati Patels) harbour a view similar to one you WRONGLY portray - Naari-Hatyakari Modi and BJP's poison

b) Sikhs have a similar view; but they change AND accommodate, at time of need

c) Hindu women, have an INSTANT LIKING for Muslim men - NOT ONLY as portrayed in the movie; but in real life of Khans, and many Muslim Men - in India

d) Some (NOT ALL) Muslim men "portray" a "wrong view" OR "partial message" of Islam to ignorants, and others pick that "wrong message" to highlight it for wrong purpose(s) !!!

e) Christians are the most accomodative, when others including Muslims offer sincere help

f) Hindus immediately believe in "whatever JUNK" is spelled by their Godmen OR Politicians OR Media, and resort to violence - including RIOTS / KILLINGS of innocent.

g) Stupid LGBT "Anonymous". Check statistics of any country w.r.t. male VS female population. FEMALE percentage is ALWAYS MORE than MALES. Islam gives that right to marry more than one wife, to solve "women" who remained unmarried, and minimizes chances of going astray, or falling prey to gazing / lusty looks of strange men.

Have you NOT HEARD about rampant "female" infanticide, "sex determination of child in womb" in India, "dowry" harrassment cases, "daughter-in-law" burning cases - in India ???

Open your eyes. Clear your SAFFRON eye-lenses, and get the message / moral in an UNBIASED manner.

Thanks

An Indian

P.S.:
-------
In Hinduism:
Cow is God, Elephant is God, Snake is God, Sun is God, Statue is God. There are Gods for everything from wealth, education, rain, prosperity, marriage, having children, etc. etc. etc. to whatever a devotee wants....... and Brahmin Pujaris fulfill that need, including abuse of women

In Islam:
All power BELONGS to ONE GOD - the Supreme and Almighty !!! We come empty handed, and leave this world empty-handed. We only take with us GOOD or BAD deeds, for which there is REWARD or PUNISHMENT.

Etch the above message in your HEAD, for the rest of your life !!!

Pages